AWARD OUTCOME
What happened
Coventry City Council published an award and contract notice for music-tutoring services under its pseudo Dynamic Purchasing System. The notice records one active award to three named sole traders and an active contract valued at £70,807.58; the contract record gives a signing date of 30 September 2026.
Published outcomeOne active shared award, ID 098102-2026-1, names Ludovic Merkelbach, Liam Halloran and Melinda Toparti. The published £70,807.58 contract value is shared and is not allocated between suppliers or lots.
Market significanceThe award concerns education and training services supporting music tuition in Coventry-area delivery locations. Quality was weighted at 100% and cost at 0% for all published lots, although those lots are marked cancelled in the same source.
AWARDED SUPPLIERS AND LOTS
3 supplier records analysed
Ludovic Merkelbach
90% confidenceAward 098102-2026-1 · Shared contract value; individual allocation not published GBP · Active award supplier; identity unverified
View supporting evidence
The active award names Ludovic Merkelbach. Supplier record identifies the party as a sole trader, but the completed identity workflow returned checked_unmatched.
Liam Halloran
90% confidenceAward 098102-2026-1 · Shared contract value; individual allocation not published GBP · Active award supplier; identity unverified
View supporting evidence
The active award names Liam Halloran. Supplier record identifies the party as a sole trader, but the completed identity workflow returned checked_unmatched.
Melinda Toparti
90% confidenceAward 098102-2026-1 · Shared contract value; individual allocation not published GBP · Active award supplier; identity unverified
View supporting evidence
The active award names Melinda Toparti. Supplier record identifies the party as a sole trader, but the completed identity workflow returned checked_unmatched.
LIFECYCLE
Award or contract stage
Notice type
99% confidenceAward and contract notice
View supporting evidence
Release history tags are award and contract; published notice type is "award, contract".
Award status
98% confidenceActive
View supporting evidence
Award 098102-2026-1 has status "active".
Contract status
98% confidenceActive
View supporting evidence
Contract 098102-2026-1 has status "active".
Contract signature
98% confidenceSigned on 30 September 2026
View supporting evidence
Contract 098102-2026-1 records dateSigned as 2026-09-30.
Lot status
99% confidenceLots 1–3 are marked cancelled
View supporting evidence
Lots for individual/small-group tuition, whole-class/ensembles and music curriculum each have status "cancelled".
VALUES
Published values explained
Published contract value
98% confidence£70,807.58
View supporting evidence
Active contract 098102-2026-1 records value amount 70807.58 GBP.
Value allocation
98% confidenceShared value; no supplier or lot allocation published
View supporting evidence
The contract contains one total value, while the award names three suppliers and supplies no allocation.
TIMELINE
Procurement timeline
Notice published
99% confidence16 October 2026
View supporting evidence
Published_at is 2026-10-16T15:39:27+01:00.
Contract signed
98% confidence30 September 2026
View supporting evidence
Contract dateSigned is 2026-09-30T00:00:00+01:00.
Notice coverage period
95% confidence1 July 2026 to 30 September 2026
View supporting evidence
The notice description states that it covers this period.
SCOPE
What was awarded
Service
93% confidenceMusic tuition and related music curriculum delivery
View supporting evidence
The description covers recruitment and retention of external music tutors for Coventry schools, communities and professional partner venues; published lot titles describe tuition, ensembles and curriculum.
Classification
99% confidenceCPV 80000000 — Education and training services
View supporting evidence
Tender classification and all items use CPV 80000000.
Delivery region
97% confidenceUKG33
View supporting evidence
All published delivery addresses specify region UKG33.
DPS validity
90% confidenceExpiry no later than 31 August 2028
View supporting evidence
The description says the pseudo DPS has been extended and expires no later than this date.
PROCEDURE
Procedure and competition
Procedure
99% confidenceOpen procedure
View supporting evidence
Tender procurementMethod is open and procurementMethodDetails is "Open procedure".
Commercial arrangement
97% confidencePseudo Dynamic Purchasing System under the Light Touch Regime
View supporting evidence
Tender description explicitly describes the arrangement this way.
Award criteria
98% confidenceQuality 100%; cost 0%
View supporting evidence
Each published lot lists quality 100 and cost 0.
Bid and evaluation information
99% confidenceNot published
View supporting evidence
No bid counts, tenderer names beyond award suppliers, scores or evaluation narrative are supplied.
CONTRACT TERMS
Published contract terms
Contract record
98% confidenceActive contract 098102-2026-1
View supporting evidence
The contracts array records ID 098102-2026-1, linked to the award, with active status.
Contract start and end dates
99% confidenceNot published
View supporting evidence
Top-level contract_start_at and contract_end_at are null; the contract record supplies only dateSigned.
Extension terms
94% confidenceNo contract-level extension terms published
View supporting evidence
The source describes DPS validity only and does not provide contract extension terms.
COMMERCIAL VIEW
Commercial observations
Award structure
98% confidenceThree suppliers share one active award and one published contract value
View supporting evidence
One award lists all three suppliers and its linked contract contains one total value.
Lot allocation
99% confidenceNot published and cannot be inferred
View supporting evidence
The active award has no lot IDs, while all three published lots are cancelled.
Quality emphasis
98% confidencePublished lot criteria place all stated weighting on quality rather than cost
View supporting evidence
Each lot lists quality 100 and cost 0.
DATA QUALITY
Gaps and source limitations
Supplier identity verification
99% confidenceAll three supplier names are unverified
View supporting evidence
Each completed identity lookup has status checked_unmatched; no verified company name or number is supplied.
Award-to-lot ambiguity
99% confidenceThe active award is not linked to a published lot, while all listed lots are cancelled
View supporting evidence
Award lot_ids are absent and all three tender lots have status cancelled.
Value allocation
99% confidenceInformation not supplied in the published notice
View supporting evidence
The contract gives one total value but no supplier-level or lot-level allocation.
Contract timing
99% confidenceInformation not supplied in the published notice
View supporting evidence
A signing date is available, but no contract start or end date is supplied.
SOURCE DATA LIMITATIONS
Information not supplied in the published notice
- All three named suppliers have checked_unmatched identity status: the Companies House workflow completed without a safe company match, so their names are unverified.
- The source presents an active award and active signed contract but marks every listed lot as cancelled; no award-to-lot allocation is provided.
- The £70,807.58 contract value is a shared total and cannot be attributed to any individual supplier or lot.
- Information not supplied in the published notice: award date, tender deadline, contract start date, contract end date, bid count, evaluation scores, pricing breakdown, individual allocations, and contract-level renewal or extension terms.
MARKET THEMES
Relevant award themes
Coventry City CouncilCoventry Musicmusic tutor DPSmusic tuition contracteducation and training servicesLudovic MerkelbachLiam HalloranMelinda Toparti
COMMON QUESTIONS
About this award
Who received the Coventry Music Tutor DPS award?
The active award names Ludovic Merkelbach, Liam Halloran and Melinda Toparti. Their identities remain unverified because completed checks found no safe company match.
What is the contract value?
The linked active contract is valued at £70,807.58 GBP. The notice does not allocate this total between the three suppliers or across lots.
Was the contract signed?
Yes. The contract record explicitly gives a signing date of 30 September 2026.
Which lots were awarded?
No award-to-lot allocation is published. The three listed lots are each marked cancelled, despite the active award and contract record.
ProcuraAxis award analysis supplements, but does not replace, the official award notice, contract data or procurement documents. “Awarded” does not by itself prove that a contract has been signed.