AWARD OUTCOME
What happened
NHS South Yorkshire Integrated Care Board published a record concerning continuation of General Dental Services at Whitegates Dental Practice in Doncaster. The structured record shows an active award and an active contract with a dateSigned of 8 October 2026, but the notice narrative describes an intention to award, says the contract had not yet formally been awarded, and the only lot is marked cancelled.
Published outcomeWhitegates Dental Practice is the supplier named on the active award record for lot 1. Its legal company identity is unverified because the completed matching workflow found no safe Companies House match.
Market significanceThe notice describes continuity of NHS dental access and existing NHS activity in Doncaster. Published financial information is inconsistent: the contract record states £167,000 while the lot narrative states £174,000 per annum.
AWARDED SUPPLIERS AND LOTS
1 supplier record analysed
Whitegates Dental Practice
86% confidenceAward 097149-2026-1 · Lots 1 · Unknown: no award-level value is published; contract and lot narrative values conflict GBP · Named on an active award record; supplier legal identity unverified
View supporting evidence
Award 097149-2026-1 names Whitegates Dental Practice as supplier and relates to lot 1. Supplier verification status is checked_unmatched.
LIFECYCLE
Award or contract stage
Published notice status
98% confidencePublished as an award, contract notice on 14 October 2026
View supporting evidence
Release history tags the notice as award and contract; published_at is 2026-10-14T15:43:33+01:00.
Structured award record
95% confidenceActive
View supporting evidence
Award 097149-2026-1 has status active.
Structured contract record
95% confidenceActive; date signed recorded as 8 October 2026
View supporting evidence
Contract 097149-2026-1 has status active and dateSigned 2026-10-08T00:00:00+01:00.
Narrative procurement position
98% confidenceIntention to award; narrative says the contract had not yet formally been awarded
View supporting evidence
The procurement rationale states that this is a PSR intention to award notice and that the contract had not yet formally been awarded.
Lot status
98% confidenceCancelled
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 is marked cancelled in the tender data.
VALUES
Published values explained
Structured contract value
95% confidence£167,000
View supporting evidence
Contract 097149-2026-1 records value amount 167000 GBP.
Lot narrative value
95% confidence£174,000 per annum
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 narrative states that the contract value will be £174,000 per annum.
Lifetime value
96% confidenceNot provided
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 narrative says the General Dental Service contract is let in perpetuity and its lifetime value cannot be provided.
TIMELINE
Procurement timeline
Contract signature date recorded
95% confidence8 October 2026
View supporting evidence
The contract record has dateSigned 2026-10-08.
Notice publication
98% confidence14 October 2026
View supporting evidence
Published_at and release date are 2026-10-14.
Representations deadline stated
95% confidence26 October 2026
View supporting evidence
The procurement rationale says representations must be made by 26/10/2026.
Service start
93% confidenceAs soon as possible; no fixed date supplied
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 narrative says the service will start as soon as possible; process contract_start_at is null.
SCOPE
What was awarded
Service
96% confidenceGeneral Dental Services, including care for existing regular patients, new patients and urgent dental treatment
View supporting evidence
Process description.
Classification
99% confidenceCPV 85130000 — Dental practice and related services
View supporting evidence
Tender classification.
Delivery area
96% confidenceDoncaster (UKE3)
View supporting evidence
Item delivery location is Doncaster and delivery address region is UKE3.
Continuity objective
94% confidenceMaintain dental access and contracted NHS activity at Whitegates Dental Practice
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 narrative describes continuity for regular patients and retention of contracted NHS activity.
PROCEDURE
Procedure and competition
Procedure recorded
98% confidenceLimited procedure / award procedure without prior publication of a call for competition
View supporting evidence
Process procurement_method is limited and procurement_method_details states award procedure without prior publication.
Regime stated in narrative
97% confidenceProvider Selection Regime (PSR), Most Suitable Provider process
View supporting evidence
Procurement rationale and lot narrative.
Evaluation criteria
95% confidenceMost suitable provider process key criteria: quality 100; cost 0
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 awardCriteria lists quality 100 and cost 0.
Competition information
99% confidenceNumber of bidders and comparative evaluation results unknown
View supporting evidence
Information not supplied in the published notice.
CONTRACT TERMS
Published contract terms
Duration
94% confidenceNo end date stated; narrative describes the GDS contract as let in perpetuity
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 narrative; process contract_end_at is null.
Options
98% confidenceNo options
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 hasOptions is false.
Contract conclusion status
99% confidenceUnclear due to conflicting structured and narrative fields
View supporting evidence
The contract record is active with a signed date, while the rationale says it is an intention to award and not formally awarded; lot 1 is cancelled.
COMMERCIAL VIEW
Commercial observations
Commercial continuity
93% confidenceThe notice characterises this as an existing service with a new supplier and links the award to continuity of local dental access.
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 narrative.
Incumbent context
94% confidenceThe narrative says the incumbent contract holder had died and refers to awarding to the remaining partner at the practice.
View supporting evidence
Lot 1 narrative.
Value reporting caution
99% confidenceThe £167,000 structured contract value and £174,000 annual narrative value are inconsistent and should not be reconciled without clarification.
View supporting evidence
Contract value field and lot 1 narrative.
DATA QUALITY
Gaps and source limitations
Conflicting lifecycle evidence
99% confidenceStructured award and contract records are active and include a signature date, but the narrative says this is only an intention to award and the lot is cancelled.
View supporting evidence
Award/contract records, procurement rationale and lot status.
Conflicting financial evidence
99% confidenceThe published contract value is £167,000, whereas the lot narrative states £174,000 per annum.
View supporting evidence
Contract value and lot 1 narrative.
Supplier identity limitation
99% confidenceWhitegates Dental Practice is an unverified source name; the Companies House matching workflow completed without a safe match.
View supporting evidence
supplier_identity_status checked_unmatched; lookupDecision still_unmatched.
Unpublished information
98% confidenceInformation not supplied in the published notice includes a fixed service start date, contract end date, award date, bidder count, individual evaluation results and pricing reconciliation.
View supporting evidence
Relevant fields are null or absent.
SOURCE DATA LIMITATIONS
Information not supplied in the published notice
- The record contains unresolved lifecycle contradictions: active award and contract fields, a recorded signature date, intention-to-award wording, and a cancelled lot.
- Published financial fields conflict: £167,000 in the contract record versus £174,000 per annum in the lot narrative.
- The named supplier has no verified legal company identity: the completed Companies House matching workflow returned checked_unmatched.
- Information not supplied in the published notice includes award date, fixed start date, end date, bid count, evaluation results, individual lot value and a pricing reconciliation.
MARKET THEMES
Relevant award themes
NHS South Yorkshire Integrated Care BoardWhitegates Dental PracticeGeneral Dental ServicesDoncaster dental servicesProvider Selection Regime
COMMON QUESTIONS
About this award
Who is named on the award record?
Whitegates Dental Practice is named on active award 097149-2026-1. The source name remains unverified because no safe Companies House match was found.
What is the contract value?
The structured contract record states £167,000, while the lot narrative states £174,000 per annum. The notice does not reconcile these figures.
Is the contract definitively concluded?
The record is contradictory: it contains an active contract with a recorded signature date, but the narrative says it is an intention to award and not formally awarded, and the lot is cancelled.
ProcuraAxis award analysis supplements, but does not replace, the official award notice, contract data or procurement documents. “Awarded” does not by itself prove that a contract has been signed.