HSF Engagement Letter for Provision of Legal Services In Relation to the Remediation Unit

Scope, procedure and submissions

Id

C103403

Status

complete

Procurement Method

limited

Main Procurement Category

services

Procurement Method Details

Award procedure without prior publication of a call for competition

Why this procedure was chosen

In 2020, Post Office Limited ("POL") established the Historical Shortfall Scheme, later renamed the Horizon Shortfall Scheme ("HSS"), for those who experienced shortfalls relating to previous versions of Horizon. In 2021, the Overturned Conviction Scheme ("OC" and together with HSS the "Schemes") was established for those whose Horizon-related convictions have been overturned by the Courts. Given that Herbert Smith Freehills LLP ("HSF") were appointed to represent POL in the group litigation raised by Sir Alan Bates & Others and that they advised POL in the mediated settlement, which gave rise to the HSS, POL appointed the same firm to provide legal services and support the administration of the Schemes, including the conduct of claim assessments, provision of legal advice in relation to scheme criteria, the establishment and operation of the independent HSS panel and various other matters. HSF has continued to support the Schemes since then. In October 2024, POL ran a competition under the Crown Commercial Service ("CCS") Legal Services Panel (RM6179) to appoint an alternative legal adviser to support the Schemes. Following that competition, POL awarded a contract to Pinsent Masons LLP ("PM") to replace HSF. However, in order to effect an orderly transition of the services from HSF to PM and to ensure that the ongoing administration of the Schemes is disrupted as little as possible in this time, POL requires a new contract with HSF (the "Transitional Contract"). POL has awarded the Transitional Contract to HSF under the light touch regime of the Public Contracts Regulations ("PCR") in accordance with the provisions of regulation 75(2) and 32(2)(b)(ii) because HSF is the only supplier that can provide the transitional services thereunder. HSF is the only contractor that is capable of providing the transitional services because only it has the knowledge of the Schemes to be able to transfer to PM. HSF was closely involved in the design and initial operation of the Schemes, it has assessed thousands of HSS cases, it holds the contracts with the independent HSS panel and holds data and documentation that POL requires, will continue to require, and will need to be transferred to POL and PM. Competition would be absent if POL was to attempt to take the Transitional Contract to market. HSF is the only organisation that is technically capable to transfer the knowledge, data and documentation that it holds to POL and to PM. It would not be technically possible to appoint another firm to provide the transitional services on HSF's behalf. There is no reasonable alternative to awarding the Transitional Contract to HSF. It would not be feasible for POL to sever its relationship with HSF without services, documentation, data and knowledge having transferred to PM. If POL was to allow its relationship with HSF to lapse without a contract for the transitional services, this would have caused significant disruption to the Schemes and would almost certainly cause substantial delay in the provision of redress to postmasters. There is no alternative to the transitional services and only HSF is capable of providing those services. This will ensure that reasonable steps are taken to see that there are no delays in redress being paid to victims of the Horizon IT scandal that are attributable to the transition of services to PM from HSF. The absence of competition is not caused by any artificial narrowing of the parameters of the procurement. POL has opened the provision of legal services to support the Schemes to competition by conducting a further competition under RM6179. This has led to the appointment of PM. It is necessary to award the Transitional Contract to HSF to facilitate the transfer of services and only HSF can do that.

Lots and requirements

Items and delivery

Buyer, suppliers and contacts

Award information

Contracts and changes

Recorded locations

• Buyer location · London · UKI31 · EC2V7ER · United Kingdom
• Delivery location · UKI